Deep Chocolate Super-Premium Ice Cream

Rich, traditional, American milk chocolate super-premium ice cream

Four-time North American Ice Cream Association Blue Ribbon Winner (‘20, ‘21, ‘22, ‘23)

french vanilla bean Super-Premium Ice Cream

Rich, traditional, American milk chocolate super-premium ice cream

Two-time North American Ice Cream Association Red Ribbon Winner (‘22, ‘23) and two-time White Ribbon Winner (‘20, ‘21)

Fresh Strawberry Super-Premium Ice Cream

Strawberry pureé (with seeds) super-premium ice cream with hunks of real, fresh strawberries

North American Ice Cream Association Blue Ribbon Winner (‘22) and three-time Red Ribbon Winner (‘20, ‘21, ‘23)

Blackberry Chocolate Chunk Super-Premium Ice Cream

Blackberry flavored super-premium ice cream with real blackberries and chocolate chunks

Cookie Monster Super-Premium Ice Cream

Bright blue cookie dough super-premium ice cream made with molasses, brown sugar, chocolate chip cookie dough, and crushed Oreo cookies

Buttermilk Pie Super-Premium Ice Cream

A very unique cream! Vanilla super-premium ice cream with hunks of genuine, house-baked Cockeye BBQ buttermilk pies, fresh from the kitchen.

Peanut-Butter Pie Super-Premium Ice Cream

One of our best sellers! Reese’s super-premium, peanut-butter ice cream with a graham cracker and marshmallow streak, and chocolate chunks

Butter Pecan Super-Premium Ice Cream

Traditional butter pecan super-premium ice cream made with Hillson (CLE) salted, buttered pecans suspended in a smooth, nutty base.

Pistachio Super-Premium Ice Cream

Pistachio flavored super-premium ice cream made with plenty of real Hillson (CLE) salted pistachios

Blueberry Cheesecake Super-Premium Ice Cream

A Cockeye Creamery classic: sweet and luscious blueberry cheesecake flavored super-premium ice cream made with real, fresh blueberries and hunks of cheesecake

Wired! Super-Premium Ice Cream

Third Day Coffee Roasters’ fresh-ground Black Lab Espresso super-premium ice cream with chocolate chunks and brownies

Chocolate Pecan Super-Premium Ice Cream

Mild chocolate super-premium ice cream with Hillson (CLE) salted, buttered pecans

White House Super-Premium Ice Cream

Halved maraschino cherries suspended in our French Vanilla Bean super-premium ice cream

Spumoni Super-Premium Ice Cream

Three-in-one! An Italian ice cream classic: chocolate, pistachio, and black cherry super-premium ice creams swirled into one delicious flavor